What Shoes Should I Squat In? Heels or Flats?
Squatting is a favorite exercise for most of us… or maybe none of us. Either way, some of us may come to a crossroads when it comes to deciding what to wear on our feet when doing the movement. The choice between squatting in weightlifting shoes (raised heel shoes) or flat shoes is a topic of considerable debate amongst lifters. This blog explores the considerations for both regular gym goers and powerlifters when choosing between these two types of footwear for squatting.
Weightlifting Shoes
1. Mechanics and Benefits:
Improved Depth and Posture: Weightlifting shoes allow for greater ankle dorsiflexion. This can facilitate deeper squats and a more upright torso position, which is beneficial for individuals with limited ankle mobility.
Enhanced Stability: The rigid sole and secure fit provide a stable base, reducing the likelihood of foot pronation and enhancing force transfer from the legs to the ground.
Quad Emphasis: The altered mechanics can shift the emphasis towards the quadriceps, which can be advantageous depending on the individual's training goals. This holds true for other exercises aside from squats as well such as leg press, hack squat, belt squat, lunges, split squats etc… the raised heel promotes more forward knee travel which biases the quads.
2. Considerations for the Regular Gym Goers:
Mobility Issues: For those with ankle or hip mobility issues, raised heel shoes can help achieve proper squat depth and form, potentially reducing the risk of injury.
Cost and Accessibility: Weightlifting shoes can be relatively expensive and may not be necessary for casual lifters or those not facing mobility challenges.
3. Considerations for Powerlifters:
Competition Standards: Many powerlifters prefer raised heel shoes for squat events due to the improved depth or if they are more quad dominant.
Individual Preference: Some powerlifters may prefer the biomechanical advantages, while others might find them unnecessary or uncomfortable depending on their personal lifting style and body mechanics.
Flat Shoes
1. Mechanics and Benefits:
Natural Movement: Flat shoes promote a more natural foot movement and can enhance the engagement of the posterior chain, including the glutes and hamstrings.
Versatility: They are versatile for various exercises beyond squats, such as deadlifts, where a flat, stable base is advantageous. Do NOT deadlift in raised heel shoes. The flatter the shoe, and closer to the ground you are for deadlifts and deadlift variations, the better.
Cost-Effective: Generally more affordable and accessible, making them a popular choice for beginners and those on a budget.
2. Considerations for Regular Gym Goers:
Mobility Requirements: Proper squat form in flat shoes requires good ankle and hip mobility. Individuals lacking in these areas may struggle to achieve proper depth and maintain balance. Individuals not lacking in these areas may prefer the comfort and more natural feel of a flat shoe.
Minimalist Approach: Those who prefer a minimalist approach to training might favor flat shoes for their simplicity and the natural feel they provide.
3. Considerations for Powerlifters:
Deadlift Preference: Powerlifters will utilize flat shoes on deadlifts to reduce the distance the bar needs to travel and to enhance stability.
Training Specificity: Powerlifters who train for a variety of lifts might find flat shoes more practical for their overall training needs, despite potentially opting for raised heel shoes during specific squat-focused sessions. However, many powerlifters may still prefer flat shoes for squats depending on comfort and individual biomechanics.
Conclusion:
The choice between weightlifting shoes and flat shoes for squatting depends on individual needs, preferences, and goals. For the general population, raised heel shoes can be beneficial for those with mobility issues or those looking to improve their squat depth and posture. Flat shoes, on the other hand, offer a cost-effective, versatile option that promotes natural movement, provided the individual has adequate mobility.
For powerlifters, the decision often hinges on specific lifting mechanics and competition standards. Raised heel shoes can provide a competitive edge in squat events, while flat shoes may be preferred for deadlifts and overall training versatility.
Ultimately, the best approach is to experiment with both types of footwear to determine which provides the optimal balance of comfort, performance, and safety for your individual needs.
Are you looking for a coach? Get started today by applying for coaching here>> Contact — THE CREW (sheridanstrengthcrew.com)